Now that the September Federal Reserve interest rate cut is behind us, I’m looking for increased attention to signs of risk in stocks trading at record highs.
Not that I expect much in the way of selling. But we could have an outbreak of handwringing as buyers keep on buying while bemoaning signs of increasing risk and speculation.
Top of my list of speculative yellow lights is the rapid increase in margin loans as traders and investors borrow money to buy more stocks even as–or maybe “because” would be more accurate–share prices continue to climb.
Margin loans on the New York Stock Exchange rose to $1.06 trillion in August 2025—an increase of over $139 billion in just the last three months and up 33% year-over-year. This rapid climb includes an 18% jump over two months. This is among the fastest surges in margin loans on record.
As of July 2025, margin debt hit $1.023 trillion, up 1.45% from June and 26% higher than last year. By August 2025, margin debt rose further to $1.06 trillion, marking new all-time highs. Margin debt now stands at 3.5% of US GDP, a level not seen since 2021.
Margin debt tends to rise when stocks are in a bull market rally. So this isn’t unexpected. The S&P 500 is up about 15% year-to-date as of September 2025. When measured relative to the market capitalization of the S&P 500, margin debt is historically high in absolute dollars, but still below its record as a share of market cap. (Currently ~1.9% versus a 2.3% long-term average).
For those unacquainted with margin debt, the borrowing of money against the current value of holdings increases the risk of forced selling and volatility during market corrections.The rapid growth in margin loans is seen as a sign of late-cycle behavior, raising yellow flags about potential market volatility.
One important thing to remember about margin loans is that if a downside move is large enough to trigger demands from margin lenders for selling to cover loan balances, borrowers are as likely to sell market leaders–positions in stocks where they have unrealized gains–as to liquidate positions in more average performers.
High levels of margin loans don’t cause crashes or downturns but it can make a selloff more bigger and faster.
Just one more thing to watch as you try to figure out risk ad reward in this rally.
