Select Page

One of the hardest things to figure out in an effort to value AI neocloud and data cener stocks is how real caclulations of future orders are–and therefore how much to pay for them when pricing a stock.

The answer seems to be “Not very.” Which certainly doesn’t make me want to pay up for these stocks.

Look at what’s happening at Microsoft (MSFT) now. Microsoft helped create the neocloud boom by signing tens of billions of dollars in contracts with data center operators in an effort to satisfy the appetite for its cloud and AI services. Now, as neocloud companies grapple with delays, regulatory snags and high costs, some key Microsoft leaders have developed a case of buyer’s remorse. The company is tightening oversight of some data center projects from Nebius Group, IREN, and Nscale, stepping away from ones it deems risky and debating internally whether to ink new neocloud deals.

The friction was on display during Microsoft’s most-recent earnings call, when Chief Financial Officer Amy Hood said that delays in the delivery of some third-party capacity was disrupting the company’s spending plans. It was the third time she has called out such issues on an earnings call.

It’s a risky time for the neoclouds, which were created to capitalize on a shortage of computing power by speeding up the deployment of artificial intelligence infrastructure, including chips from Nvidia. Industry analyst Gartner Inc. recently estimated that 80% of neocloud providers could be consolidated or closed by the end of the decade. Elon Musk-— whose SpaceX competes in the market for selling computing power–offered a similarly bleak outlook of “guppy-level death” for many neoclouds because they’re struggling to raise sufficient funds to operate.

Microsoft was the neocloud industry’s most crucial early patron, providing the likes of CoreWeave and Nscale with massive contracts that let them get big quickly. Even though Microsoft has a huge fleet of data centers, it was willing to pay up to meet demand it couldn’t handle on its own. “We’ve had to pinch our nose and borrow GPUs from some of our competitors,” Microsoft Executive Vice President Mat McBride said of the company’s neocloud deals during a conference hosted by Evercore in June. “We’ve done that because we have a very, very strong demand signal.”

Increasingly, Microsoft is putting boots on the ground to verify that neocloud suppliers will be able to meet their schedules. In recent months, the company has dispatched workers to neocloud sites to make sure facilities are being built to its specifications and following regulations. For example, Microsoft sent workers to a Nebius site in New Jersey that was fined $1 million for running generators without permits. Microsoft has also sent people to projects in Texas being built by Nscale and IREN.

In other cases, Bloomberg reports, Microsoft is walking away from sites it no longer considers tenable, including multiple Nscale projects. It declined to expand its deal with Nscale in Texas, and some of that capacity ended up being taken by Figure AI. Microsoft also stepped away from a letter of intent to lease 1.35 gigawatts from the company in West Virginia.

And last month it canceled a roughly $3 billion Nscale deal tied to a UK data center owing to multiyear delays in getting grid power, according to people familiar with the deal. Nscale said at the time that the UK withdrawal didn’t impact its other deals with Microsoft.

Microsoft is currently focused on expanding its own data centers rather than adding new neocloud deals, according to Bloomberg reporting. The company hasn’t entirely sworn off new neocloud deals, but many company leaders express strong reluctance, the people said. Over the last year, Microsoft has added more than $200 billion of new data center lease commitments. Some of this includes neocloud capacity, according to a spokesperson. All of this spending is being directed toward major expansion of its own server farm capacity in the coming years, Bloomberg previously reported.

Nebius has been unusually upfront with its competitive strategy. It will scale up by inking contracts with big customers like Microsoft or Meta Platforms Inc. knowing that they’ll abandon neoclouds in the long run, Nebius CEO Arkady Volozh said during a March conference hosted by Morgan Stanley.

“We treat this business as temporary,” Volozh said, referring to his company’s deals with customers like Microsoft and Meta. “They just cannot cope with the speed now — that’s why they’re outsourcing.”

Demand for computing power remains much higher than supply–and is expected to remain so or the foreseeable future. So even if Microsoft decides not to sign new neocloud deals, Anthropic and Google have been accelerating their own commitments to data center operators.