Select Page

Another day, another 9-basis-point jump in the yield for 10-year Treasuries. The yield hit 5.20% today and is now up 51 basis points in a month and 106 basis points, that’s a little more than a full percentage point, in a year. (Remember rising yields mean falling bond prices.)

These are extraordinarily big moves in the normally slow-moving Treasury market. And this high degree of volatility is itself producing worry and hedging and selling in the bond market.

Yesterday’s, Wednesday’s, really weak auction of five-year Treasury debt–ranked as the second-worst auction by one measure in data recorded since 2018–needed the highest yield since 2006 to clear the market.

Thursday’s seven-year note auction wasn’t as bad but it was still pretty bad. It cleared at a 5.085% yield, about 0.7 basis point above the 5.078% when-issued yield level. Before the actual bidding, expectations on Wall Street were that the $44 billion auction would draw a yield near 5.05%, exceeding all previous results for sales of the maturity since its 2009 reintroduction.

What was especially worrying about the weak auction was that it included a buyback operation targeting as much as $6 billion of debt maturing in 20 to 30 years. The size of the auction was about three times as much as originally planned. The first expanded buyback–part of Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent’s plan to lower yields for 10-year and longer maturities–on September 10, targeted $6 billion maturing in 10 to 20 years, but netted only $5.2 billion. That deepened the sell off since it reinforced doubts that the buybacks can control rising yields.

Given the forces at play, “bonds are actually behaving rationally,” Amy Xie Patrick, a money manager at Pendal Group, told Bloomberg.

Oh, good, what looks like panicked selling, is actually rational selling. Strategists at JPMorgan Chase and KKR & Company see scope for U.S. yields to climb further as energy-driven inflation, heavy government borrowing, and the risk of additional central-bank tightening continue to depress prices. The bond market loves round numbers–now that we’ve broken through 5%, I don’t see any reason selling can’t take yields to 5.5%.

Swaps now fully reflect three quarter-point hikes over the next year from the Fed, with significant hedging for a fourth.

The selling is global. The selloff boosted yields on German 10-year bonds to 3.59%, the highest since 2009, while Japanese 10-year yields climbed about 10 basis points to 3.09%. The Japanese move is actually shocking to me. The Bank of Japan’s usual “core” CPI measure—excluding fresh food but including energy—rose at a 1.7% rate in August. That means Japanese bond yields in real terms–that is after inflation–are actually positive after years of zero or below zero interest rate policy. Japan’s short-term real interest policy rate was at or below zero for the overwhelming majority of the period since the late 1990s: broadly from 1999 to 2024, roughly 22–25 years, with brief intervals of mildly positive real rates during periods of deflation.

Global government bonds have lost around 2.4% this year, compared with a 6.8% gain last year, according to the Bloomberg Global Bond Aggregate Index. The index posted its biggest one-day loss since May on Wednesday.

Rising volatility is adding to the gloom, making investors hesitant to buy even as higher yields make bonds more attractive. The ICE BofA MOVE Index, which measures U.S. bond market swings, climbed Wednesday to the highest level since March. “Most fixed income will like higher yields, but want them to be stable there,” Hans Mikkelsen, strategist at TD Securities, told Bloomberg. Investors are “afraid of catching a falling knife,” he said.

Photo by Andrew Dawes on Unsplash